Whether you like your lashes long, wispy or voluminous, we’re confident you’ll find your perfect match among the best Maybelline mascaras.
The makeup brand has earned a reputation for crafting high-quality formulas that don’t flake, clump, or droop — and all at affordable price points. In fact, Maybelline made it onto our list of the best budget mascaras, TWICE.
So are you and Sky High soulmates? Or do you bleed neon pink and green for Great Lash? Find ‘the one’ to suit your desired lash look here…
The best Maybelline mascaras
@beautyheavenau If you like fluttery lashes, you need to know about this mascara #mascarareview #beautyeditor #budgetmakeup #maybellinefalsieslashlift ♬ Cool Kids (our sped up version) – Echosmith
Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara
$26 at Woolworths
Best for: Length
“the mascara has a smooth consistency and does not clump on the eyelashes. it is mostly used for extending the lashes rather than creating volume though which may be off putting for some other people. the wand is thin and bendy which is very useful. i purchased the black version and i have no regrets at all i love it and use it on the daily.” – Zoee
Read more Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Sky High Mascara reviews
Maybelline Falsies Lashlift Mascara
$26 at Woolworths
Best for: Dramatic lashes
“After all the hype around Sky High, I totally slept on this gem of a mascara. It’s got great lift, separation and completely coats each lash in colour. But the best part is that it stays on without flaking and holds its curl all day. Obsessed.” – bh’s Sam.
Maybelline New York Colossal Volum’Express Mascara
$19.95 at Adore Beauty
Best for: Volume and separation
“I love trying out new mascaras, but always find myself coming back to this one. It volumises the lashes so well and multiple coats can be applied easily without getting too clumpy. I do find that the wand helps to separate too and doesn’t flake off as much as some other maybelline mascaras I’ve tried.” – Lianatriesmakeup
Read more Maybelline New York Colossal Volum’Express Mascara reviews
Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Mascara
$25 at Woolworths
Best for: Short and straight lashes
“Favourite mascara hands down! No matter how many high end mascaras I try, i always come back to the Lash Sensational. Super lengthening and volumising without any clumps and lasts the whole day without smudging through the day. The wand separates and coats each individual lash really well and really does create the “full fan effect” Holds the curl really well, even with my short and straight lashes.” – Lily777
Read more Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Mascara reviews
Maybelline New York Great Lash Lots of Lashes Mascara
$9.95 at Chemist Warehouse
Best for: Budget
“I’ve been using this mascara for as long as I can remember and I haven’t had any issues with it. I just wanted a simple affordable mascara, nothing fancy and still does the same job as any other mascara. Glides on nicely with no clumps. This product is regularly on sale for under $10. Considering it’s just a basic mascara which gives you a natural result, you get what you pay for but it’s worth it.” – Jas84
Read more Maybelline New York Great Lash Lots of Lashes Mascara reviews
Maybelline Full ‘n Soft Mascara
$17 at Woolworths
Best for: Natural-looking (and feeling) lashes
“I have tried many mascaras that have left me totally disappointed. I have quite long and thick lashes so I really like mascaras that don’t make lashes super exaggerated thick or clumpy and hard. This one gave my lashes a very natural finish, leaving them very soft and without any clumps or looking extra fake.” – Spitfire
Read more Maybelline Full ‘n Soft Mascara reviews
What’s your favourite Maybelline mascara? Have you tried any of the above?
Love the colossal one in the yellow tube. My sister got me onto it after a makeup artist recommended it to her.
I tried to find your review for this, but you haven’t written one yet, Izzy!
I concur with the Maybelline New York Colossal Volum’Express Mascara.
Yeah it’s pretty good hey
I must try this
zesxrdctfvygbhnj
Add all to cart! I’ve seen that Sky High mascara recommended so many times.
Not had much experience with Maybelline masacara – except for the Great Lash which I didn’t like
I have used Maybelline in the past and would use it again.
yes indeed a good brand
They are great value for money, I used some , can’t remember which one.
Great Lash in the classic green & pink tube was my first mascara – I’ll forever miss the matching liquid eyeliner that got deleted. Full ‘n Soft was my favourite years ago. I wanted to read reviews for Falsies Lashlift, but it’s not listed – it sounds up my alley.
It looks like a fun one -Love the colours
same hhere wanna try the soft brown tho
I tend to use cheap mascara as I don’t often wear makeup, expensive ones are a waste of money because they dry out before I’ve had a chance to use them up and have to be thrown away.
The lash sensational mascara is pretty good!
qwecfvgbhnjkm
might need to get it
I have tried some of these and look forward to giving others a go.
wsdefgh
So many great options here
I’d love to try the Falsies Lash Lift! So glad I saw the video. Thanks Sam. : )
The sky high mascara is so good.
dcfvtgybhunjikolp
righht
I love a good mascara -nothing nicer
I recently picked up the Colossal mascara for $10 and so I probably can’t complain but I cannot keep this mascara on my lashes. It always ends up under my eyes. I haven’t had this issue with any others. Otherwise it looks great when it goes on and you can’t beat the price, but it ends up making me look like a panda every time.
I’ve been using Sky High since it hit the shelves and it’s the only one I use. I also use the waterproof one due to if I watch a sad movie, tears will swarm. I have now found the best waterproof mascara also so win win. I do have a sample of colossal to try so will compare. Before Sky High I did use Sensational but for me it’s Sky High all the way. I also have short, light sparse lashes so they make mine look longer.
I love the Lash Sensational Mascara! It works well with my long, straight lashes.
They all look good.
oh yes so true
yes, but for me only tubing mascara works.
Ωdcftvgybhunjimk
what an actual…
Not a brand I use often, but it is reliable.
Have recently bought the sky high one but haven’t used it yet.
Full ‘n Soft first mascara i eer brought
I seem to have tried most of them.
Need to try the falsies
some blast from the past there
Great value and quality
Sky High is an excellent mascara.
Maybelline sure do a great mascara